Kingdom Society, Part I

Lets try a series on for size. This one promises to be scattered due to the fact that it is 2:30 in the morning and I have a lot that I want to lay as base-work for this series.
I like the idea of communism at the basic level. This is not to say that I have a good grasp of the ideology of it as a whole, I’m going to be researching some of that for this series. However, the idea that all work together for the common good, which then in turn will benefit you, is a very, oddly enough, Christian idea. All should pitch in to make a better living for all. Community.
Capitalism, on the other hand and again oddly enough, is built upon a very non-Christian idea: Work for the good of yourself, which in turn should benefit society. Self-centered vs. others-centered. Here in America, it is well known that we hail capitalism and the free-market system as the solution to the worlds problems. But is it a system worthy of the followers of Christ?
Capitalism works, or has worked very well in the past for one reason in my opinion: It is a system designed to work on the principal that man is selfish. Its the perfect system for a world of sinful, selfish people.
After an entire night of talking over a wide variety of very interesting subjects with my new housemate, James, I have thought through something else as well. Only one thing was necessary for a Biblically historical account of a “Fall” to make sense: the entrance of selfishness into Man’s desires. A change from desiring the good for either someone else or for all others before one’s self, to a desiring of the betterment of one’s self above all others. This single change in perspective, in my opinion, can account for all sin or evil in the world, aside from things like natural disaster and the like, which, even so, may be attributable to man’s poor management and use of the earth. Another topic for another time.

Back to the topic at hand, communism has failed historically because ultimately, someone, somewhere gets the idea that this system is exploitable for his/her own good. Because of this, the people who are then taken advantage of, suffer miserably under the hand of tyranny. Then dissent leads to revolution and the downfall of a system. All stemming, again only in my opinion, from selfishness.
So what is the solution? Not so fast, we’ve barely begun! And its getting near 3. But the answer is anarchy…. Not yet
More to follow.
Meanwhile, you can all read Animal Farm, a decent, semi-humorous novel/commentary on communism in what most resembles the former Union of Soviet Socialist Republics. Its a shorter read, although it is a book. See you all soon.



I totally agree with a lot of your thinking here! Please keep going if you have time and/or feel lead.
Collin B.
May 21, 2009 at 7:47 pm
interseting, and worthy of further conversation. at least, this commentary has a bit of explaining to do.
capitalism, at its core, is a recognizing of inherent sinful human nature, one which will not compute with a system so confoundedly optimistic as communism. see: history.
that being said, you’re asking tough questions. far too often, american evangelicals synchronize the american flag with kingdom loyalty. this cannot be. keep writing.
carl henry
May 21, 2009 at 9:01 pm
Carl: I totally agree that Christianity and America need to be forever separated as two entirely separate entities. They have been tied together for far too long. We are NOT a Christian nation. There is no such thing in my opinion. But that’s another topic.
I agree that capitalism works because it is built on how things are. If anything, its one of the greatest cases for the existence of human tendency to default to sin. “The Fall” if you will. However, I wonder as Christ’s followers, should we work for or be proponents of a system that is based on sinful tendencies, or should we champion something better, more ideal, seek to make it practical? Is that possible? I am unsure. Hence this conversation
Thanks for your insight.
plukevdh
May 26, 2009 at 4:56 pm
If I ever get married I’m going to start a household communist party, open to my honey and me only. It really can work.
Johnjohn
October 3, 2009 at 12:38 pm